I first met Dr. Helen Gurney-Smith in fall 2024, when Dr. Shannon Meseck and I drove just beyond the U.S.-Canada border to the St. Andrews Biological Station in New Brunswick. We went there to study larval sea scallop respiration when exposed to near-future temperature and pH. This past winter, Dr. Gurney-Smith’s research group drove south to visit us at the NOAA Fisheries Milford Lab in Connecticut. We studied how a proposed method of marine carbon dioxide sequestration may affect the single-celled phytoplankton community in the ocean.
This project was a part of a collaborative effort funded by the NOAA Ocean Acidification Program to engage early-career scientists from U.S. and Canadian fisheries agencies in ocean acidification research. Brady Quinn was the co-principal investigator on this project. Quinn, along with Dr. Gurney-Smith, and Erin Miller made up the Fisheries and Oceans Canada team, while Dr. Meseck, Genevieve Bernatchez, Lauren Witick, and I represented NOAA Fisheries.
Studying the Effects of Buffering Ocean Water with Olivine
Increasing carbon dioxide dissolved in the ocean causes ocean acidification, which is a concern for ecosystems. It’s especially harmful for marine life that build calcium carbonate shells, which can degrade in seawater with lower than normal pH. There are several proposed mechanisms to help keep the pH up in the ocean, including methods to increase alkalinity, effectively buffering seawater. One method is to add a naturally occurring mineral known as olivine to high-risk areas. As olivine dissolves in seawater, it breaks down into parts that can raise the pH of the water, making it less acidic. This works much like taking an antacid for an upset stomach.
When olivine breaks down it releases several elements phytoplankton need to grow, including the trace metals magnesium and iron, along with silica. Silica is an important nutrient for the growth of some phytoplankton, called diatoms. Diatoms are an excellent food for shellfish and other small marine grazers. Similar to plants, they can make oxygen from carbon dioxide through photosynthesis, making them an integral part of marine ecosystems. These diatoms use silica to create a glass-like cell wall, and it is possible that the release of extra silica from olivine could stimulate their growth.
Although olivine is a promising solution to ocean acidification, there is a lot we don’t know about how it affects the marine environment. Will the extra silica benefit diatoms? Will diatoms and other phytoplankton take up the trace metals, and if so, will it be too much and possibly become toxic to them? These are the questions we wanted to answer with this project, and we used some unconventional tools to find our answers: brewing fermenters! These containers have been adapted by the Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Pelagic Impact Intercomparison Project to keep these kinds of experiments standardized and comparable across labs.
A Mesocosm Experiment Made From Home-Brewing Equipment
We didn’t ferment anything, and you certainly wouldn’t want to drink the seawater inside. But it turns out that off-the-shelf, home-brewing equipment works pretty well as a small, replicable sampling unit, or mesocosm! It allowed regular environmental sampling under controlled conditions. The bottle design lets us keep outside air out, minimizing new carbon dioxide entering the system and allowing us to sample from the bottom in roughly half-liter increments. We also included a heat belt around the middle and bottom of the bottles to mix the water through a process called convective overturn—the same process that brings nutrients to the surface of the ocean from the deep.
We set up 12 fermenters in our lab’s greenhouse for the experiment. Each was filled halfway with seawater containing its natural plankton community and the other half was one of four treatments:
- 100 percent olivine-enriched filtered seawater
- 50 percent olivine-enriched filtered seawater
- 100 percent synthetic olivine in filtered seawater
- A control of only filtered seawater
We took daily measurements of the seawater chemistry, chlorophyll concentration, and phytoplankton cell counts. We also took measurements of the metals in the water and in the particles in the water at the beginning and end of the experiment.
Because of the natural spring light coming through the greenhouse, the plankton in the bottles grew in all treatments. We noticed the olivine treatments had far more of a green tint to the water than the others by day two, which is a good indicator of phytoplankton growth. Our chlorophyll measurements and cell counts agreed: The olivine provided something that allowed more phytoplankton to grow compared with the controls. We expected to find the answer in either the dissolved nutrients or in metals analysis, as these are two constituents that could be leached by the olivine.
We expected the phytoplankton to take up the metals from the olivine, increasing the concentration of metals in the particulate samples. Surprisingly—despite olivine being enriched in chromium, cobalt, and nickel—the metals released by the olivine did not appear to be taken in by the phytoplankton. These metals naturally occur in lower concentrations in seawater, and phytoplankton require small amounts of each to live. It appears the cells were not taking in more than they needed during the course of this experiment. Even more surprisingly, the olivine did not appear to add much iron to the water or plankton, despite it being a major part of the mineral composition.
Potential Relationship Between Olivine, Eutrophication, and Coastal Acidification
Nutrient analysis showed that olivine contributed nitrogen to the phytoplankton in the experiment. Nitrogen is an important nutrient needed for all life on Earth. In excess, it can cause phytoplankton blooms and contribute to eutrophication and, in turn, coastal acidification.
Excess nutrients can cause phytoplankton to grow in abundance quickly, and they may degrade before they can be grazed by zooplankton and shellfish. As bacteria start to decompose the excess phytoplankton, they use oxygen and release carbon dioxide. This both depletes the oxygen available for marine life and lowers the pH of the water.
In this experiment, we observed that olivine addition could increase the alkalinity and pH of the seawater without contributing excess heavy metals to the phytoplankton. This was a short-term study, however, and we do not yet know what long-term effects olivine addition could have. Further tests are needed to understand the potential role of olivine in coastal acidification and how it may affect other marine life. Our experiment indicates that, while it may not harm the phytoplankton community, additions will need to be small to limit the amount of nitrogen they add to the ecosystem.