SEDAR 68 CIE Reviewer Report - Cardinale
Southeast Fisheries Science Center
Document
(DOC)
| ID: 71738
| Published / External
Created: 2023-12-26
|
Last Modified: 2023-12-26
Project (PRJ) | ID: 64965
ID: 71738
Document (DOC)
* Discovery• First Pass
» Metadata Rubric
Item Identification
* » Title | SEDAR 68 CIE Reviewer Report - Cardinale |
---|---|
Short Name | |
* Status | Completed |
Creation Date | |
Revision Date | |
• Publication Date | 2021-11 |
* » Abstract |
This document is the individual CIE Reviewer report of the SEDAR 68 Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico Scamp assessment conducted during August-September 2021 and provided at the request of the Center for Independent Experts (CIE). This report solely represents the view of the independent reviewer (Prof. Massimiliano Cardinale). The text in this report is mainly based on the original assessment reports and background documents provided to the reviewer in advance of the meeting. The Assessment team tackled all the assigned terms of reference (TORs). The reviewer considers that the Assessment team has done a satisfactory job in carrying out the assessment, analysing all available data, modelling part of the uncertainty and providing some sensitivity analyses of both the data and the models. However, the reviewer does not completely agree with all of the findings reported in the SEDAR 68 Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico Scamp assessment report. Taking into account all available information, the reviewer considers that a single best model cannot be singled out to be used for advice. Instead, given the uncertainties in the data used as input, and in key biological parameters and processes, a model ensemble should be developed in the future. |
* Purpose |
Independent peer review report of the SEDAR 68 Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico Scamp assessment review Prepared for the Center for Independent Experts By Professor Massimiliano Cardinale |
Notes | |
Other Citation Details | |
• Supplemental Information | |
DOI (Digital Object Identifier) | |
DOI Registration Authority | |
DOI Issue Date |
Keywords
Theme Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
Temporal Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
* Spatial Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
Stratum Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
Instrument Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
Platform Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
Physical Location
• » Organization | |
---|---|
• » City | |
• » State/Province | |
• Country | |
• » Location Description |
Document Information
Document Type | |
---|---|
Format | |
Format Version | |
Status Code |
Support Roles
* » Support Role | Distributor |
---|---|
* » Date Effective From | 2022 |
Date Effective To | |
Organization | SEDAR |
Address |
4055 Faber Place North Charleston, SC 29405 United States |
Email Address | |
Phone | (843) 571-4366 |
Fax | |
Mobile | |
URL | http://sedarweb.org |
Business Hours | |
Contact Instructions |
* » Support Role | |
---|---|
* » Date Effective From | |
Date Effective To | |
* » Contact | |
* Contact Instructions |
* » Support Role | |
---|---|
* » Date Effective From | |
Date Effective To | |
* » Contact | |
* Contact Instructions |
* » Support Role | |
---|---|
* » Date Effective From | |
Date Effective To | |
* » Contact | |
* Contact Instructions |
Extents
Currentness Reference |
---|
Extent Group 1
Extent Description |
---|
Extent Group 1 / Geographic Area
* » W° Bound | |
---|---|
* » E° Bound | |
* » N° Bound | |
* » S° Bound | |
* » Description |
Extent Group 1 / Vertical Extent
EPSG Code | |
---|---|
Vertical Minimum | |
Vertical Maximum |
Extent Group 1 / Time Frame
* » Time Frame Type | |
---|---|
* » Start | |
End | |
Alternate Start as of Info | |
Alternate End as of Info | |
Description |
Access Information
* » Security Class | |
---|---|
* Security Classification System |
|
Security Handling Description |
|
• Data Access Policy |
|
» Data Access Procedure |
|
• » Data Access Constraints |
|
• Data Use Constraints |
|
Metadata Access Constraints |
|
Metadata Use Constraints |
|
Distribution Information
Start Date | 2022 |
---|---|
End Date | Present |
» Download URL | https://sedarweb.org/documents/sedar-68-cie-reviewer-report-cardinale/ |
Distributor | SEDAR (2022 - Present) |
File Name | sedar-68-cie-reviewer-report-cardinale.pdf |
Description | |
File Date/Time | |
File Type (Deprecated) | |
Distribution Format | PDF - Adobe Portable Document Format |
File Size | 844k |
Application Version | |
Compression | Uncompressed |
Review Status | Chked Viruses Inapp Content |
Start Date | |
---|---|
End Date | |
» Download URL | |
Distributor | |
File Name | |
Description | |
File Date/Time | |
File Type | |
FGDC Content Type | |
File Size | |
Application Version | |
Compression | |
Review Status |
Start Date | |
---|---|
End Date | |
» Download URL | |
Distributor | |
File Name | |
Description | |
File Date/Time | |
File Type | |
FGDC Content Type | |
File Size | |
Application Version | |
Compression | |
Review Status |
Start Date | |
---|---|
End Date | |
» Download URL | |
Distributor | |
File Name | |
Description | |
File Date/Time | |
File Type | |
FGDC Content Type | |
File Size | |
Application Version | |
Compression | |
Review Status |
URLs
URL | |
---|---|
Name | |
URL Type | |
File Resource Format | |
Description |
URL | |
---|---|
Name | |
URL Type | |
File Resource Format | |
Description |
URL | |
---|---|
Name | |
URL Type | |
File Resource Format | |
Description |
Activity Log
Activity Time | |
---|---|
Activity Type | |
Responsible Party | |
Description |
Activity Time | |
---|---|
Activity Type | |
Responsible Party | |
Description |
Activity Time | |
---|---|
Activity Type | |
Responsible Party | |
Description |
Issues
Issue Date | |
---|---|
Author | |
Issue |
Issue Date | |
---|---|
Author | |
Issue |
Issue Date | |
---|---|
Author | |
Issue |
Data Quality
Representativeness |
|
---|---|
Accuracy |
|
Analytical Accuracy |
|
Horizontal Positional Accuracy |
|
Vertical Positional Accuracy |
|
Quantitation Limits |
|
Bias |
|
Comparability |
|
Completeness Measure |
|
Precision |
|
Analytical Precision |
|
Field Precision |
|
Sensitivity |
|
Detection Limit |
|
Completeness Report |
|
Conceptual Consistency |
|
» Quality Control Procedures Employed |
|
FAQs
Date | |
---|---|
Author | |
Question | |
Answer |
Child Items
Rubric scores updated every 15m
Score | Type | Title |
---|---|---|
Related Items
Item Type | Relationship Type | Title |
---|---|---|
Catalog Details
Catalog Item ID | 71738 |
---|---|
Metadata Record Created By | Lee M Weinberger |
Metadata Record Created | 2023-12-26 12:17+0000 |
Metadata Record Last Modified By | Lee M Weinberger |
» Metadata Record Last Modified | 2023-12-26 22:53+0000 |
Metadata Record Published | 2023-12-26 |
Owner Org | SEFSC |
Metadata Publication Status | Published Externally |
Do Not Publish? | N |
Metadata Workflow State | Published / External |
Metadata Last Review Date | 2021-07-26 |
Metadata Review Frequency | 1 Year |
Metadata Next Review Date | 2022-07-26 |
Tags |
---|