SEDAR 8 RD-26: Performance indices that facilitate informed, valuedriven decision making in fisheries management. 2004. Bull. Mar. Sci 74(3) 709-726
Document (DOC) | Southeast Fisheries Science Center (SEFSC)GUID: gov.noaa.nmfs.inport:60057 | Updated: October 17, 2023 | Published / External
-
View As
- Full List View
- Printable Form
- EXPORTS
- InPort XML
- View in Hierarchy
Summary
This paper develops and explores the use of five indices representing resiliency, yield productivity, yield constancy, capacity constancy, and ecosystem productivity to evaluate natural-resource management alternatives. Too frequently, managers and their scientific advisors have miscommunications because managers want simple answers to complicated questions and scientists are uncomfortable providing information that might seem value-laden. Indices can give managers a framework within which to ask for scientific advice and scientists a mechanism for presenting likely consequences of management decisions without favoring particular values. Five quantitative indices representing common fishery management objectives are developed, and their use is illustrated through tests of various control rules in simple simulated-population models. The results provide an example of how to meld societal values with scientific analyses in the policy arena. They also give insight into the effectiveness of various control rules and highlight better alternatives to current practices. The benefits of such an approach extend well beyond fisheries management. Many natural-resource policy processes share the characteristics that make the use of multiple performance indices valuable, including unpredictability, complexity, and diversity of opinion.
Document Information
Document Format
Acrobat Portable Document Format
Publication Date
2004
Distribution Information
-
PDF - Adobe Portable Document Format
Contact Information
Distributor
SEDAR
(843) 571-4366
Item Identification
Title: | SEDAR 8 RD-26: Performance indices that facilitate informed, valuedriven decision making in fisheries management. 2004. Bull. Mar. Sci 74(3) 709-726 |
---|---|
Publication Date: | 2004 |
Abstract: |
This paper develops and explores the use of five indices representing resiliency, yield productivity, yield constancy, capacity constancy, and ecosystem productivity to evaluate natural-resource management alternatives. Too frequently, managers and their scientific advisors have miscommunications because managers want simple answers to complicated questions and scientists are uncomfortable providing information that might seem value-laden. Indices can give managers a framework within which to ask for scientific advice and scientists a mechanism for presenting likely consequences of management decisions without favoring particular values. Five quantitative indices representing common fishery management objectives are developed, and their use is illustrated through tests of various control rules in simple simulated-population models. The results provide an example of how to meld societal values with scientific analyses in the policy arena. They also give insight into the effectiveness of various control rules and highlight better alternatives to current practices. The benefits of such an approach extend well beyond fisheries management. Many natural-resource policy processes share the characteristics that make the use of multiple performance indices valuable, including unpredictability, complexity, and diversity of opinion. |
Other Citation Details: |
Bull. Mar. Sci 74(3) 709-726 |
Keywords
Theme Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
UNCONTROLLED | |
None | growth |
None | mortality |
None | Panulirus argus |
None | spiny lobster |
Spatial Keywords
Thesaurus | Keyword |
---|---|
UNCONTROLLED | |
None | Caribbean |
None | Puerto Rico |
Document Information
Format: | Acrobat Portable Document Format |
---|---|
Status Code: | Final |
Support Roles
Distributor
Date Effective From: | 2005 |
---|---|
Date Effective To: | |
Contact (Organization): | SEDAR |
Address: |
4055 Faber Place North Charleston, SC 29405 United States |
Phone: | (843) 571-4366 |
URL: | http://sedarweb.org |
Distribution Information
Distribution 1
Start Date: | 2005 |
---|---|
End Date: | Present |
Download URL: | https://sedarweb.org/docs/wsupp/SEDAR8%20RD26.pdf |
Distributor: | SEDAR (2005 - Present) |
File Name: | SEDAR8 RD26.pdf |
File Type (Deprecated): | |
Distribution Format: | PDF - Adobe Portable Document Format |
Compression: | Uncompressed |
Review Status: | Chked Viruses Inapp Content |
URLs
URL 1
URL: | https://www.ingentaconnect.com/contentone/umrsmas/bullmar/2004/00000074/00000003/art00016 |
---|---|
URL Type: |
Online Resource
|
Description: |
Landing Page To Download Paper |
Catalog Details
Catalog Item ID: | 60057 |
---|---|
GUID: | gov.noaa.nmfs.inport:60057 |
Metadata Record Created By: | Lee M Weinberger |
Metadata Record Created: | 2020-06-17 21:14+0000 |
Metadata Record Last Modified By: | SysAdmin InPortAdmin |
Metadata Record Last Modified: | 2023-10-17 16:12+0000 |
Metadata Record Published: | 2020-06-18 |
Owner Org: | SEFSC |
Metadata Publication Status: | Published Externally |
Do Not Publish?: | N |
Metadata Last Review Date: | 2020-06-18 |
Metadata Review Frequency: | 1 Year |
Metadata Next Review Date: | 2021-06-18 |